Direction 04 · Verdict-first

The appraisal is
the interface.

A portal tells you what's listed. A buyer's agent tells you what it's worth. So we lead with the moat: every property arrives as a verdict you can judge — a comps-derived call (over / fair / under), a fair-value band, a confidence badge, and "see the comps." You don't browse listings; you act on appraisals. Buy · Pass · Ask the agent. Chat isn't the front door — it's "ask about this verdict."

􀋧

Verdict + provenance

The hero object is the Appraisal Card. Every verdict opens to the sold comps that produced it — each a tappable, agency-direct source. Cite or abstain, made physical.

􀎶

KNOW vs RATE

Computed, auditable numbers look distinct from the agent's interpretation. The agent writes the verdict and explains it; it never invents the figure.

􀉪

Confidence is first-class

Thin comp density → the agent says so. A high/med/low badge driven by comp count rides on every verdict, so a buyer knows how much to trust it.

􀇿

Honest gaps

"Strata & flood — not in our data" is a designed element, not a silence. No faked completeness.

Shared language Computed fact (KNOW · cited) Agent's read (RATE · narration)
▲ Over comps ✓ Fairly priced ◆ Under comps
Conservative · shippable
A

Appraisal Report

The listing is a deal report. One scannable scroll: verdict → fair-value band → the 6 comps → fit checklist → area — then act.
IdeaA per-listing deal report led by the verdict. The full case, top to bottom.
InteractionScroll & tap; sticky Pass · Ask · Shortlist. Tap any comp → its source.
TradeoffLowest risk, highest trust. Familiar layout; nothing hidden behind gesture.
Open variant A 􀰫
Middle ground
B

Verdict Feed

Opens on a digest ("found while you slept: 3 strong fits") — a scroll of compact verdict cards, each a mini-appraisal you act on inline.
IdeaA proactive, ranked-by-value feed. The appraisal card, repeated & scannable.
InteractionScroll; inline Pass · Comps · Shortlist. Live agent-working note + skeletons.
TradeoffMore inventive than a report, safer than a swipe — reversible, fully scannable.
Open variant B 􀰫
Bold · inventive
C

Swipe Stack of Verdicts

Each home is a card to judge. Swipe Pass / Shortlist, tap Ask, or flip the card for the comp evidence. Triage a week in a minute.
IdeaVerdict on the front, provenance on the back. Fast triage of pre-appraised supply.
InteractionSwipe Pass/Shortlist; flip for comps. Opens on an agent-working state.
TradeoffFastest, most delightful — but a gesture on a $4m call is bold; evidence stays one tap away.
Open variant C 􀰫
How to read these. Each mockup runs live in a ~390×844 phone frame — open one in its own tab and tap around. Variant C plays an agent-working / reasoning state on load (replayable from design notes); Variant B shows a live loading/skeleton state (tap "resolve loading"); every variant exposes a provenance/citation surface (the comps behind a verdict). Each has a small design notes affordance (bottom-right) explaining the interaction, why it fits a buyer's agent, and what's faked vs real.

Content & data. Real Eastern-Suburbs Sydney suburbs & realistic numbers (Bondi, Coogee, Randwick, Bellevue Hill); imagery via picsum.photos. In production every cited figure is live data — sold comps, $/m², SEIFA block decile, school catchments, GTFS transit — surfaced as the agent's auditable basis. Built for the Lynx/Luna dark advisor aesthetic.